Zinc Casting vs Other Processes

Zinc casting, also known as zinc die casting, is a popular process for manufacturing a wide range of products. With its ability to cast to tighter tolerances and at a lower cost, zinc casting is a preferred choice for many industries. This “Net Shape” manufacturing process frequently reduces or eliminates the need for costly machining or welding because the casting can be “3 dimensional” with features that protrude from other surfaces.

Benefits of Casting in Zinc Over Aluminum

When considering the advantages of zinc casting and other processes, it is important to highlight the advantages that zinc offers over aluminum.  

One major benefit is the superior dimensional accuracy achieved with zinc. The high fluidity of molten zinc allows intricate and complex designs to be reproduced with precision. Therefore, resulting in parts with tight tolerances.  

Zinc components may be accurately cast to finished dimensions with greater precision and hence avoid machining. Aluminum die casting more often requires secondary machining, in addition to adding cost tends to expose porosity. 

Zinc die castings have lower casting costs. Aluminum has a higher melting temperature and is cast with a slower process. As such, the casting process of zinc has a higher rate and thus a lower cost for production.   

Zinc tools can last up to 10 times longer than aluminum tools. Having a long-lasting tool can represent significant cost savings and help ensure stability in quality and production.  

Additionally, zinc die casting offers excellent surface finish options. With the ability to produce smooth and polished surfaces without the need for extensive post-processing. Almost any finish may be applied to the zinc die castings.  

Since aluminum must be much hotter than Zinc, the thermal shock generated in the casting process produces a part with a surface that can be more pitted. Many finishes amplify these defects. This makes zinc an ideal choice for applications where aesthetics and fine details are crucial. 

Zinc alloys may be cast in thinner walls. Thin-walled casting can have superior strength to weight ratio. Thus, strong, and light zinc casting may be designed using the minimum of metal. This also improves the production rate and lowers costs.  

Overall, the benefits of zinc over aluminum make it a favorable choice for various industries. Along with manufacturing requiring intricate designs, dimensional accuracy, and production efficiency. 

Zinc Die Casting vs Other Processes

Benefits of Zinc Over Stamping from Sheet Metal or Coil Stock

When examining the advantages of zinc casting compared to stampings from sheet metal or coil stock, several key benefits become apparent.  

Firstly, zinc casting allows for greater design flexibility and complexity. Die castings are producible in more complex shapes than what is possible in a stamped form.

Stamping from sheet metal or coil stock offers economy that is difficult to equal when a component is flat or with features with simple bends, but when features are more 3 dimensional and complex then castings are more ideal.  

With stamping, there are limitations on the shapes and forms that can be achieved, whereas zinc casting offers the ability to create intricate and detailed components with ease. This is particularly advantageous for industries that require unique and customized parts.  

Additionally, zinc casting provides superior dimensional accuracy and tight tolerances, ensuring that the final product meets precise specifications. Unlike stamping, which may result in slight variations or imperfections, zinc casting produces consistent and high-quality parts.

Moreover, the use of zinc casting eliminates the need for additional post-processing steps, such as welding or joining, which are often required in sheet metal stamping.

More complex shapes are often produced by assembling several stampings, usually by spot welding. A cost-effective choice may be zinc casting when a complex stamping or several stampings are required.

This not only saves time and resources but also enhances the overall efficiency of the manufacturing process.

Material costs for stamping may be higher than indicated by published per pound cost due to high scrap rates. Stamping invariably consumes more material than is contained in the end product. The process often requires peripheral material for clamping the sheet metal in the die. Therefore, significant amounts of metal are removed from the perimeter and from the interior openings. Die casting, as noted above, is very material efficient, as any excess material can be remelted and used without degradation.

Overall, the benefits of zinc casting over stamping from sheet metal or coil stock highlight its versatility, precision, and cost-effectiveness in producing complex and accurate components.

Zinc Casting vs Injection Molded Plastics

When comparing zinc casting to injection molded plastics, there are notable distinctions. Zinc casting offers distinct advantages in terms of strength, rigidity, durability, and dimensional stability. Zinc allows for robust components that can withstand harsh conditions and heavy loads. Die casting has a high degree of permanence under load when compared to plastics. Zinc parts are completely resistant to ultra-violet rays, weathering and stress-cracking in the presence of various reagents.

In contrast, injection molded plastics may be more susceptible to wear and tear, especially in high-stress applications. Plastic parts are more prone to warping and surface defects such as “sinking” which is an imperfection resulting in uneven cooling. Since zinc casting cools in a rigid way, it provides excellent dimensional stability, ensuring that the final product maintains its shape and size after it is processed and solidified.

Zinc castings are also preferred over plastics for components operating at elevated temperatures. The melting temperatures of die casting alloys are 2-3 times higher than the typical plastics. In many applications plastic components are protected from heat sources. Die castings do not have similar concern and such can simplify design and reduce costs.

When decorative components require a durable finish, zinc die castings are usually selected. Superior surface characteristic allows zinc to be powder coated, plated, painted and chromated with little to no surface preparation. In addition, the high density of zinc imparts a feeling of strength and quality that cannot be matched by plastic.

In conclusion, when considering the properties of strength, durability, dimensional stability, finishing and cost, zinc casting proves to be a compelling choice over injection molded plastics in certain applications.

Conclude Why Zinc Casting vs Other Processes

Overall, after learning about the physical characteristics and process benefits of zinc casting, we can confidently say that it is a suitable and cost-effective method for meeting important design criteria.

While other processes may have their own advantages, zinc casting stands out for its versatility, precision, and durability. We hope you “think zinc” and have a clear understanding of zinc casting and its benefits for your next design project.

Design and Engineering at Deco Products

With over 20 engineers with over 400 cumulative years of experience, your new product project is in good hands.
Dave Magner

Dave Magner

Dave Magner is the Director of Sales and Marketing and has been with Deco Products since 2015. He has a +20 years of engineering experience in mechanical and electrical testing and design and zinc die casting, plastic injection molding, stamping, assembly, and automation processes.

Quick Links

Sign Up To Deco's Quarterly Newsletter

No spam! Just relevant news, events, and updates about Zinc, Deco, and our services. Sign up for our quarterly newsletter today!

Sign Up To Deco's Quarterly Newsletter

Deco Products is committed to protecting your privacy.  By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance to the terms defined in our full Privacy Policy statement.